My Ex’s Family Helped Him Avoid Paying Child Support. I Turned Them All In, But It Didn’t Go As Planned.
Pay Dirt is Slate’s money advice column. Have a question? Send it to Kristin and Ilyce here. (It’s anonymous!)
I have an ethical question about blame. My ex got paid under the table by his parents’ large family business, and used this to avoid child support for almost six years. This situation was kind of an open secret in our area. My ex’s brother started doing the same thing a few years ago. It sucked, but there wasn’t much I could do about it because I was broke and trying to tread water for my kids after the divorce. His family is a big deal in our county and his cousin is close friends with my landlord, so I didn’t want to make waves. Finally, I had my own life together enough and realized I could report the situation to the IRS. It took a long time, but they finally untangled things and it’s much worse than I’d realized. His parents will actually do jail time for shady money practices. He won’t (which is better for our kids), but he’s been assessed for significant back child support. If he works legally, his wages will be garnished wherever he works going forward. He is in a field where under the table work is usually uncommon, so I’m hoping this will actually make a difference.
But because this secret wasn’t very secret, no one knows who originally tipped off the IRS. I’d always been so compliant with my kids’ dad that the family is convinced that it’s his brother’s ex, seeking child support for her kids and also revenge for a really messy relationship. They’re being pretty nasty to her in a public way, including my ex-mother-in-law getting her fired from her job. I don’t know what to do. I don’t want them to turn on me, and I can’t afford to lose any of the stability we’ve built. But she doesn’t deserve this either! What do I do?
I get your conundrum: You did the right thing for entirely legitimate reasons—securing child support your kids deserved—but now an innocent person is taking the heat. This puts you in an incredibly difficult position where doing the “right” thing again could torpedo the stability you’ve worked so hard to build.
Let’s be clear about what happened here. Your ex’s family created this mess through years of illegal financial scheming. They’re now lashing out at someone—a victim, no less—who had nothing to do with their downfall because they need a scapegoat. That’s on them, not you.
You’re not obligated to throw yourself under the bus to save someone else, especially when you have kids depending on your stability. But consider some middle-ground options: Could you anonymously tip off the wrongly accused ex about potential legal remedies for wrongful termination? Some employment lawyers work on contingency. Could you document the family’s retaliatory behavior in case she needs evidence later?
If the harassment escalates or becomes truly vicious, you might need to speak up—not necessarily claiming credit for the tip, but perhaps suggesting the family is barking up the wrong tree. You could frame it as “I don’t think [brother’s ex] would do something like that” rather than “I’m the whistleblower.”
No matter what, your priority has to be your children’s welfare and your family’s security. You’ve already done your civic duty by reporting tax fraud. The family’s vindictive response reveals their true character—they’d rather destroy an innocent person than accept responsibility for their own criminal behavior.
I’m glad you and your former sister-in-law have escaped this particular circle of hell.
More Money Advice From Slate
This feels shameful to write, but I am very concerned about the financial obligations I have towards paying for my stepkids’ college. I married their dad when they were young teens and preteens. At the time, they lived with their mother the next state over, and my contact with them was very limited. My husband traveled alone to visit them, and I only saw them several times a year when they came for extended visits on school breaks. Then the kids came to live with us full-time.